Count the Stars
A short story. A Caltech grad student discovers time travel. Two rabbis decide otherwise.
History was made at Caltech's Hutzler Laboratory on a rainy March afternoon. And then it wasn't.
The lab smelled of coffee and ozone, a combination that had become synonymous with their endless nights of calculations and calibrations. Their experimental device, which they'd nicknamed "Cappy" after lengthy debate and too many energy drinks, occupied the corner like a baroque sculpture of steel and copper.
Jun Kim, drummed her fingers nervously on her desk. Behind her, Marcus Chen adjusted his thick-rimmed glasses, muttering equations under his breath as he cross-referenced the incoming data against their theoretical models. Sarah Robinson sat behind her work station bathed in the monitor's glow, focused on the cascading data running across her screens.
It was Javi who had brought them together, who had first proposed the impossible theory during a late-night discussion in the department's break room. "What if," he had said, sketching on a napkin, "we could use quantum entanglement not just across space, but across time?" They had laughed then, but the math kept working out, each equation leading to another like breadcrumbs toward something extraordinary.
The monitors displayed cascading strings of quantum signatures — position, momentum, spin states — but what made their hearts race was the temporal displacement readings. They were measuring particles that, according to every known law of physics, shouldn't exist yet. The helium atoms they were tracking showed decay patterns that hadn't occurred, carrying quantum signatures from thirty seconds in the future.
"Check it again," Javi asked, his voice steady despite the adrenaline coursing through him. "Sarah, what's the quantum coherence looking like?"
Sarah's eyes darted between three different screens. "Holding steady at 99.2%. The quantum field maintains stability for far longer than we theorized. Javi, this isn't just time dilation — we're seeing actual temporal displacement!"
Marcus pushed back from his workstation, running both hands through his close-cropped hair. "The implications… if we can maintain quantum coherence at these levels, we could potentially extend the effect beyond individual particles. We could send actual matter through time."
A grin split Javi's face as the team chorused their inside joke: "Let's go stop 9/11, kill Hitler, and bet on last year's Superbowl!"
Laughter filled the lab, loud enough that no one noticed the faint, stale perfume filling the room. Like a faint whisper of chrysanthemums, it grew more distinct, silencing the students. Then, with a double pop, like balloons rupturing, two men stood before them.
Javi froze, processing their strange attire: black coats, and buttoned-up linen white shirts. The older one, grey-bearded, wore a flat-brimmed hat; the younger, a ruddy-patched beard, wore a Trilby. Their side curls fell almost to their shoulders. Amish? Mennonite? No… Jewish, Javi realized, before the young man extended a hand.
Four marble-sized spheres hovered in his palm, shimmering for only a second before embedding in each student's right eye, sending a blinding current through optic nerves.
They died instantly.
The bearded man moved closer, inspecting the experiment that had held their attention. "They were clever, very clever goyim."
"Dos ken nor a goy," the younger one shrugged. He set a small box in the center of the room, and, with one last look, they vanished with a pop.
A stream of hyper-accelerated particles erupted from the box, filling the lab with a burst of plasma that obliterated everything.
Javier Aguilar looked down into the suds of his beer on the deck of the Crown & Anchor under a string of eclectic lights. Austin's autumn hum of the "church of football" filled the air. The tab was settled, goodbyes exchanged, and his friends offered him a ride, but Javi declined; he wanted to walk. He cut through the university's empty parking lots, past buildings looming in silence.
As he turned into a dim side street, an elderly man caught his eye — a short, hunched figure under a bus stop sign, cloaked in a fringed shawl. His white beard swallowed his cheeks, and his golden yarmulke gleamed under the streetlights.
The man looked at Javi and waved as if greeting an old friend. "Javi, Javi, do you have a moment?" His accent was thick and unfamiliar.
Javi stopped, puzzled. "Do I know you?"
"No, but I'm here to help you. Walk with me." The old man shuffled closer, his hand reaching out to steady himself on Javi's arm. "I'm Haim Metzger, Rabanut Ha-Rashit Li-Yom — the rabbi of The Second Belz Great Synagogue. I know, it means nothing to a mathematician like you." His grip tightened, his gaze intent. "Have you picked your graduate program yet?"
"What?" Javi glanced around, half-expecting to see friends crouched around a nearby corner laughing at him.
Haim nodded, as if confirming something. "I'm here to fix things, Javi." He raised his left hand, sweeping forward in a broad motion. Austin vanished. Suddenly, they were standing in a room that reeked of burnt metal and ozone, the walls blackened and twisted. Javi's knees wobbled, his stomach flipping.
"What just happened?" he gasped. "Where are we?"
"Caltech. The very lab you'll apply to." Haim pointed to a dark smudge in the corner. "See that? That was you. Until recently."
"You mean… I was…" Javi choked, staring. "What's going on?"
"You were eliminated," Haim replied bluntly. "It was necessary to prevent catastrophe." He seized Javi's arm again, and they vanished from the ruined lab, reappearing on a sunlit street.
Javi stumbled, disoriented, his nostrils filling with salt air. Crowds bustled around them as he took in the sights: men in striped swimsuits, women in skirts frolicking in the waves. "Where are we?"
"Coney Island," Haim replied, handing Javi a hot dog. "1890. They've yet to build the boardwalk. This… this was always my favorite time to visit." He took a bite of his hot dog, savoring it. "People say to try the pastrami or bagels, but this, Javi — this is real New York Jewish food."
"This can't be real. 1890? New York?" Javi wiped his hands on his jacket, feeling the sand under his feet. "Either I'm dreaming, hallucinating, or…" He trailed off.
"You're not. I brought you here for perspective." Haim finished his hot dog, brushing crumbs from his coat. "You were the driving force behind the discovery of time travel. The Nobel, fame, all yours… until it wasn't."
"And the lab… that explosion? Why?" Javi asked, his voice barely a whisper.
"Think. What would you do with time travel?"
Javi's mind reeled. "Stop 9/11… save my grandmother, maybe even kill Hitler."
"Ah, exactly. That impulse, Javi, is why I'm here." Haim gestured to the beach, the people laughing in the waves. "You'd save the innocent, fix injustices — noble aspirations, but fatal ones."
"What if I succeeded?" Javi argued, following Haim as they walked the shore. "What if the Holocaust never happened?"
"Without World War II, without German scientists absorbed into American and Russian programs, you don't get a moon landing. Without the tragedies that propelled us, progress stalls." He sighed, casting his gaze over the waves. "We try to be clever. We try to be noble but every attempt to change history only delays greater horror, and humanity always suffers and is snuffed out."
They walked on, Javi absorbing the words, grappling with their meaning. "So, I had to die?"
Again the reality around them dissolves.
The night air carries the mingled scents of desert herbs — wild thyme and hyssop released by the evening dew. Each breath feels ancient, untouched by millennia of human progress. Small nocturnal creatures rustle in the scrubland, their movements accompanied by the distant bleating of sheep and the low murmur of sleeping cattle. The stars above them seem impossibly bright, unchallenged by any artificial light, spreading across the sky like scattered diamonds on black velvet.
The old man by the fire — Abraham — sits on a worn stone, his shepherd's crook beside him. His face is weathered like the surrounding hills, deep lines etched by years of desert sun and profound contemplation. His beard catches the firelight, sometimes appearing silver, sometimes gold. Though elderly, there is an unmistakable strength in his bearing, the strength of one who has walked long with purpose.
The flames cast dancing shadows on the surrounding rocks, creating an almost supernatural atmosphere. Smoke rises straight upward in the still air, as if reaching toward the very stars Abraham studies. His lips move in silent communion, and though Javi cannot hear the words, he feels their weight — the weight of a conversation that will echo through thousands of years of human history.
"Do you see the way he holds himself?" Haim whispers, though they cannot be heard. "That tension in his shoulders? He knows he stands at the fulcrum point of history. The Divine One speaks to him not just of numbers, but of destiny. Each star he tries to count represents not just a descendant, but a possibility — a branching path through time that we must shepherd."
A cool wind sweeps across the hillside, causing the fire to flicker and dance. For a moment, Javi swears he can see other figures in the firelight — ghostly shapes of people yet unborn, countless generations stretching into the future. He blinks and they're gone, but the impression lingers.
"What you're feeling now," Haim continues, noting Javi's expression, "that vertigo of possibility — that's what makes our task so crucial. Every decision, every intervention, ripples forward through time like waves in a pond. But unlike waves in water, these ripples can build upon each other, create tsunamis of change that could wash away everything. That's why we must be as Abraham is now — patient, watchful, willing to listen rather than simply act."
They watch as Abraham raises his hand to the heavens, tracing patterns in the stars as if reading divine script written in celestial light. The fire crackles, sending sparks upward to mingle with the stars themselves, momentarily indistinguishable from the eternal lights above.
"Yes," Haim said, voice soft but firm. "It's a burden you couldn't carry." He grabbed Javi's arm, and they vanished, reappearing on a windswept hill. Stars stretched endlessly above, close enough to touch. In the valley below, an encampment flickered under firelight. Nearby, an elderly man sat alone by a fire, face lifted to the heavens.
Javi instinctively paused as Haim extended a hand. "That is Abraham," Haim murmured. "He communes with the Divine tonight, hearing a promise beyond his comprehension."
"What's he being told?" Javi asked, mesmerized by the scene.
Haim pointed skyward, guiding Javi's gaze. "He's told to count the stars if he can, for his descendants will be as numerous."
Haim's voice softened as he continued, "Our people have borne the burdens of history — the Diasporas, the Holocausts, the Pogroms. We cannot erase these things. We walk on these sands, carry these scars, and yet…" He held out his hands, showing a few grains clinging to his fingers. "These few I could save — souls plucked from the stream of history."
The stars blurred as Javi's vision clouded, overwhelmed by it all.
And then they were back in Austin, the streetlights casting warm halos around them. The humidity greeting him like a wet hug. The bus turned the corner, and the rumble grounded Javi to his original reality.
Haim's gaze lingered on Javi, his voice gentle. "Go, my child. Find another path. Wonders remain in this world, but time… it's not on your side."
Javi blinked, and Haim was gone, leaving him alone under the streetlights, his path forward unknown.